Education for peace is the best vehicle to ensure that the next generation of Israelis and Palestinians will have the skills, the knowledge and the motivation to create a truly peaceful Middle East. Now is the time to look towards the next generation and to empower them with the ability to live in peace with their neighbors. Until now we have taught our children and ourselves what is necessary to survive in times of conflict. Our children must be provided with the skills and knowledge to live in peace and to create mutual respect and understanding that will enable them to transform their lives and this region into one of cooperation, prosperity and freedom.
The best way to build peace for the future at the "People-to-People" level is through educational change. IPCRI's peace education program, now entering its fifth year is rapidly entering the educational system of both sides. IPCRI's Peace Education program is the largest and most comprehensive undertaking of its kind in Israel and Palestine. IPCRI's Peace Education Project has taken a strategic approach to peace education and involves multi-disciplanry curricula (cognative elements), skills training in conflict resolution (providing new skills and practical training) and encounters between Israeli and Palestinian participants (experiential and emotive elements).
During the 1999-2000 school year, the Peace Eduation Program was conducted in 32 schools in both Israel and Palestine. In both regions we have included schools in the periphery and are no longer operating only in the center of the country. In Palestine, government schools in the Jenin and Tulkarm region have been added to the private schools that participated in the past two years. During the school year of 2000-2001 we will further expand the project and reach nearly 100 classrooms of Israeli and Palestinian 10th graders. Demand from the field has brought us into a process of developing a continuation 11th grade program for those students who participated in previous years. Working with two institutions, the Neaman Center for Negotiations and Mediation from the Technion and the Consensus Building Institute of MIT in Cambridge, Ma, IPCRI will be introducing skill building for Israeli and Palestinian students and teachers in mediation and negotiation of disputes. These tools will add communication techniques and skills in frameworks that will supplement the peace education aspects of the program learned in the tenth grade. Like the tenth grade program, the 11th grade follow-up program will include joint encounters between the participants, however, the second encounters will be held after the participants have been trained in mediation and negotiation techniques and theory.
For the past 4 years, IPCRI
has worked diligently in creating new curricula in peace education which is
becoming part of the existing curricula in schools for tenth grade students
where the program is being implemented throughout Israel and Palestine. New lessons in civics, history, sociology and literature have been
created with an emphasis on peace education. Teaching skills in conflict resolution,
mediation and negotiations are being taught to the students. The high point of
the program includes two-day long encounters between the Palestinian and
Israeli students. Our Israeli and Palestinian teams of curriculum writers will
be adding additional lessons for the history units with a greater emphasis on
studying the roots of the conflict and the peace process. All of the 48 hours
of classroom study is conducted informaly in workshop style and not "chalk and
talk" frontal education. In order
to enable the informal process, the classes are broken into two groups for all
of the lessons.
A main focus of the program
places the strongest emphasis on the teachers. The participating teachers take
part in more than 150 hours of in-service teacher training in peace education
and intensive encounters with their colleagues from the other side.
Throughout the process, IPCRI has trained more than 300 teachers and tens of facilitators who have all become professional agents of change. Uri Savir, one of the Israeli negotiators in Oslo, in his book "The Process" states that one of the main oversights of the peacemakers until now was to give too little attention to peacemaking amongst the Israeli and Palestinian peoples. IPCRI's Education for Peace Project is our premier People-to-People project and one of the most effective and successful projects of its kind.
The
project was originally initiated to penetrate the school systems of the two
societies directly implicated in the Israeli-Arab conflict (Israeli and
Palestinian), and to turn the classroom into a vehicle for rapprochement. It is
an innovative and unprecedented endeavour in which peace education curricula
were designed, while at the same time training and developing a cadre of agents
of change, namely the professionals involved in the project - principals,
teachers, curricula developers, facilitators and representatives from the
Ministries of Education. The direct encounters between the participants enhanced
the people-to-people aspect of the project.
The
project's fundamental idea was based on the decision that Israelis and
Palestinians together develop model lessons for 10th grade students (15-16 year
olds). The tenth grade was selected because of the belief that these students
have the cognitive abilities to confront the subject materials and are not yet
under the pressure of matriculation exams. The curricula, designed by professionals from the communities
involved, was first tested on a small sample of classes (the
"ambassadors"), and after a process of trial and correction,
implemented during the 1997/8 academic year in 24 Israeli and Palestinian pilot
classes and in an additional 24 schools during the 1998/99 academic year. In
the school year of 1999/2000 32 classes participated in the program.
One
of the long term goals of the project is to create an educational package made
of the curricula, teacher training and encounters both at the level of teachers
and students that will be adopted and widely used by the Ministries of
Education of the two nations, implemented through trained agents of change.
Curricula teams agreed on value statements based on the recognition and
acceptance of the other, universal values, and critical thinking.
The
uniqueness of Peace Education curricula is that it is based on existing
subjects taught in the classes.
The curricula teams took the materials in sociology/social sciences,
literature, history and English and infused this material with new concepts and
activities and added a new text.
This text, while expanding knowledge of the subject, is particularly
valuable in highlighting concepts of peace education. Teachers use this text in conjunction with their traditional
subjects to discuss peace education daily. The Peace Education curricula present an integrative,
holistic approach. The packages
have been developed by Palestinian Noor Center for Education and Israeli Adam
Institute.
Following
the tremendous success of the pilot stage of the project and many requests from
the schools participating in it, as well as from schools that have heard about
the project, IPCRI's staff is convinced of the necessity to continue its work
with the schools currently participating in the project. Furthermore, we believe that in order
for the Peace Education package to be accepted and adopted by the Ministries of
Education, we must reach a critical number of participating schools in each
country, so that the demand for the program will come from the ground up to the
Ministries themselves.
The
Israeli Ministry of Education has expressed its support for the project. The
Palestinian Ministry of Education expressed its satisfaction with the progress
made in the implementation of the project and has recommended that it be
submitted for review to the Department of Curricula Development, to consider
implementation of the project in additional schools. In order for this project to be fully adopted by each of the
Ministries of Education it is necessary to involve a much larger number of schools
and teachers and at a later time to involve the parents on a bi-nation wide
lobbying effort aimed at enhancing public and educational pressure upon the
decision makers.
In
the 1999/2000 school year, the Peace Education Program penetrated Palestinian
governmental schools for the first time.
In 2000/2001 additional Palestinian governmental schools will be added
to the project as well as two schools in Gaza for the first time. IPCRI has also made great successful
efforts to reach schools in the periphery both in Israel and in Palestine. The demand for the program from the
field is much greater than the financial ability of IPCRI to meet. For example, the education department
of the Municipality of Tel Aviv requested to have the program implemented in
all of the high schools under its authority. IPCRI selected a group of schools in Tel Aviv that contain a
wide variety of student populations and represent the southern neighborhoods of
Tel Aviv as well as the higher advantageous populations of North Tel Aviv. Emphasis has been placed on schools in
development towns and poorer communities.
In order to answer the needs, IPCRI will be receiving the financial support
of the Israeli Ministry of Education that will direct funds for the schools
through IPCRI to cover the extra hours required for the implementation of the
program.
General and specific objectives
General Objectives:
IPCRI's peace education department espouses the philosophy that while peace can be signed by statesmen, it must be built between people where parties involved in the ignorance and mutual denial of legitimacy characterize the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. The IPCRI Peace Education Program is working at the grass roots level on changing perceptions and stereotypes about "the enemy". Education for Peace teaches skills to defuse, manage, and solve conflicts, as well as universal values of peace, human rights and democracy.
A
peace process occurs between nations, transferring them from a state of war
between enemies to a state of peace between partners. A successful peace
process requires a shift of attitudes in a cross section of the society and
must be built between the peoples. This lengthy process of education should
take place through the educational system (formal and informal). Consolidation
of the fragile peace talks demands a dialogue on changing perceptions and
stereotypes about the ‘other'. It also means learning the skills to defuse,
manage, and solve conflicts. Education is a powerful agent of change and
socialization into society's major values; unfortunately, it sometimes also
acts as a transmitter of conflict-producing, or sustaining, myths. Hence the
need for a project that teaches conflict-solving values and skills and brings
together Israeli and Palestinian teachers, on equal footing, to encourage
discussion, to empower both sides, and to emphasize the role of the educators
as agents of change.
The project which IPCRI is currently
proposing, has four main specific objectives:
A. Training agents of change
Training Palestinian and Israeli teachers to use the
Education for Peace packages
|
ü A minimum of three teachers who will work on the project
ü An agreement to free the teachers for a minimum of 10 school days for training
ü Two hours per week of study for each class participating
ü Agreement to divide the class in half for all project activities in order to work in small groups
ü At least one class from the tenth grade participating
ü Agreement to have the class participate in a two day encounter
ü All extra costs for class hours are at the expense of the school (we hope to receive the support of the Israeli Ministry of Education for the hours of schools located in the periphery)
Schools are selected from varied social backgrounds Furthermore, IPCRI has made an effort this year to select schools in the periphery as well as several disadvantaged schools in order to widen the scope and nature of students participating. Teacher TrainingLiterature & English:
- Equality and Pluralism
- What is Freedom?
- Freedom and the Right of Choice
- Social Involvement
- Justice
- Human Rights
- Analysing Social and Political Trends
- Interfaith Declaration
- Conflict Resolution Skills
Sociology & Social
Sciences:
- Democratic and Non-Democratic Socialisation
- Social Divisions and Political Power
- Traditional and Modern Families
- Stability and Change
- Sociological Theories and Change of Values
- Dealing with the Concept of Democracy
- Environmental Issues
History:
- How Should we Deal with the Past?
- The Right to Self-Determination
- Refugees; the Palestinian and Israeli Perspectives
- Conflict Resolution Training Skills
IPCRI is continuing to review the curricula and to make improvements. In both curricula the section dealing with conflict resolution skills is being further developed in cooperation with the Consensus Building Institute of MIT under Prof. Lawrence Susskind. This year, IPCRI will add a follow-up program for those schools interested for their 11th grade classes on conflict resolution and negotiation skill building. The Palestinian curriculum is being developed more in the area of confronting the peace process in order to supplement that part of the program. The program for the encounter has focused on confronting final status issues. We have been experimenting with this part of the program and further development will take place this year.· Improve the intervention model of Education for Peace by IPCRI in its next phase.
· Identify the positive changes that took place on attitudinal as well as action levels, such learning enhances the peace building activities and its potential to strengthen the peace process on the level of "people to people."
· Recognize the limitations and negative consequences that might result from the intervention project.
The need to comprehensively evaluate the IPCRI Education for Peace program stems from the recognition that the project has been implemented for the last five years and only one intermediary and partial evaluation of the students' encounters was conducted in 1999. Although the partial evaluation pointed out to the strong positive impact that the encounters have produced on the Palestinian and Israeli students, nevertheless there are many other aspects that should be examined. For example, what was the impact of thisproject on the staff of teachers from the two different communities (Israeli and Palestinians). To what extent has this project influenced their personal and professional lives as agents of social change in their school systems? What type of impact did the project have on the students who have completed the program? What actual and concrete implications did the Education for Peace project have on the students and staff?
Identifying and learning the process of development and obstacles that faced this program from its inception until now can provide an important contribution to the field of peace building in post settlement or in divided societies in general. The Israel-Palestinian experience is fresh and pioneer in this area, there are no other programs in the world that have attempted to engage in such process of devising new curricula to change myths and misperceptions among old enemies. Thus learning and documenting the development of the project can offer significant lesson not only for IPCRI's future projects in this area, but for other countries as well. Finally, in terms of timing and measuring impact of Education for Peace, it is essential to try and capture the impact of the intervention as close as possible to the actual intervention, three years is a long period in the life of a teenager. Beyond this period of time it will be difficult to have participants to reflect on their past experience with the project. Methodology and experience of the principle evaluator:
(1) attitudinal changes among participants ;
(2) behavioral changes that influenced or developed among participants as a result of their participation in the project;
(3) new skills that has been learned or gained by the participants.
The proposed evaluation program would certainly include the following components:
I. Initiation period contact and coordination (February 1996-completion of the first curriculum).
The primary focus of the evaluation of this period would be on the:
a. Nature of the contact between Israeli and Palestinian educators, NGOs representatives, Ministries of education, and academicians.
b. Type of training provided to the participants and the development of the group.
c. Impact of the meetings and process of curriculum development on the members of the group.
d. Satisfaction of the group from the curriculum that was developed
II. Teacher training: the evaluation in this phase will focus on all teachers
who were trained to carry out or implement these curricula for peace in both communities (approximately 300 teachers have been trained by IPCRI staff and received 148 hours of training). The evaluation of these teacher experience can focus on the following aspects:
a. impact of the training in their attitudes towards their own community and the other community;
b. impact of the training and experience of teaching the curriculum on their personal and professional lives; and
c. teachers' perceptions of the impact of the curricula on their students and the general relations between the two communities; and
d. identify the type of skills that were gained by teachers as a result of their training in education for peace project.
III. Students' education: Evaluation in this phase can focus on the experience of the students in studying the curricula separately and their reactions to the joint sessions that they had with members of the other community. Some of specific evaluation items would relate to the following aspects:
a. impact of the curricula on the students perception of the other side;
b. impact of the meeting with the other in the encounter context on the students' perceptions; and
c. impact of the Education for Peace experience on the students' actions. (For example, have students become involved in certain activities due to their exposure to such curricula?).
d. identify specific skills that students have learned as a result of their exposure to the curriculum of Education for Peace
IV. IPCRI staff perceptions: this segment of the evaluation focuses on the perceptions
and attitudes among IPCRI staff who were involved in the project. The evaluation aims at uncovering the development of the project and the necessary changes that will improve its implementations. Thus, there are certain concepts that will be examined:
a. extent of training invested in the preparation of teacher, curricula , and project in general;
b. perceptions of success and impact that the project has had on the various participants; and
c. lessons learned from the experience working in this project.
The Facilitators
September:
·
Opening
of the school year meeting of all of the teachers
·
School
visits by staff
·
Teacher
Training workshops on Peace Education Package
·
Begin
implementation of curricula in schools
October
·
School
visits by staff
·
Follow
up teacher training
·
Lessons
being taught in schools
·
Teacher
Training
November
·
School
visits by staff
·
Lessons
being taught in schools
December
·
Veteran
teachers' encounter workshop; 5 days
·
Follow
up teacher training
·
School
visits by staff
·
Lesson
being taught in schools
January
·
School
visits by staff
·
Follow
up teacher training
·
New
teachers' encounter workshop; 5 days
February
·
Student
encounters begin
·
Follow
up teacher training
·
Newsletter
·
Curricula
modification
March
·
New
school recruitment begins
·
School
visits by staff
·
Follow
up teacher training
·
Evaluation
of curricula and further modifications
·
Student
encounters
April
·
Student
encounters
·
New
school recruitment
·
School
visits by the staff
·
Follow
up teacher training
·
Curricula
evaluation and modification
May
·
Student
encounters
·
School
visits by the staff
·
New
and old school recruitment
June
·
Student
encounters
·
School
visits
·
Evaluation
with teachers
·
Printing
and distribution of modified curricula packages
July
·
Preparations
for new teachers' training
·
Selection
of teachers
·
Workshops
for facilitators
August
·
Teachers
training
·
Distribution
of curricula packages
·
Teachers'
training for 11th grade program
Israeli Schools
· Tel Aviv High School "Daled" 9 tenth grade classes, 1 11th grade class
· Amal Lady david, Tel Aviv 4 classes
· Tel Aviv High School "Tet" 1 class
· Bat Yam Hahasmonians 3 classes
· Herzeliya Rishonim 3 classes
· Technical-Engineering High School Bosmat Tivon 1 class
· Denamrk high School Jerusalem 2 classes
· Ziv High School Jerusalem 4 tenth grade, 2 11th grade
· University High School Jerusalem 3 tenth grade, 1 11th grade
· Experimental High School Jerusalem 2 classes
· Mossad Hinuhi Tzafon 1 class
· Shaalon High School Kiryat Gat 3 tenth grade, 1 11th grade
· Ashdod "vav" 1 class
· Ashdod "Alef" 1 tenth grade, 1 11th grade
· HaEmek Hama'aravi 5 classes
· Carmel-Zvulan 4 classes
· I'balin 3 classes
· Taybe 1 class
· Kafr Qassem 2 classes
· Kafr Yassif 1 class
· El Mutran Nazareth 3 classes
A List of the Newly
Recruited Palestinian Schools
· Zababdeh Gov. Sec. Girls School Zababdeh / Jenin - 2 classes
· Anabta Gov. Sec. Sch. Boys School - Nablus - 2 classes
· Irtah Gov. Sec. Sch. Boys School - Irtah Village / Tulkarem - 2 classes
· Dar El-Kalameh Private Sec. Sch. Mixed School / Beit Sahour - 1 class
· Franciscan Sec. Sch. Boys Private / Jericho 1 class
· Franciscan Sec. Sch. Girls Private / Jericho 1 class
· Latin Patriarchs Sec. Sch. Private / Gaza 2 classes
· Assyra Ashammalyya Sec. Sch./ Gov. / A village near Nablus 2 classes
·
Shepherd Sec. Sh./ Private / Beit Jala 2
classes
· Rosary School for Girls / Beit Hanina 2 classes
· Lutheran Sch/ Mixed / Beit Sahour 2 classes
· Talitha Kumi / Mixed /Beit Jala 2 classes
· Ahliyya College / Ramallah / Mixed 2 classes
· Zababdeh Boys Elem Sec. Sch./ Jenin 2 classes
· Latin Private Sec. Sch. / Jenin 2 classes
· Ihssan Samara Sec. Sch./Tulkarm 4 classes
· Terrasancta Sec. Mixed Sch. Bethlehem 2 classes
· Taybeh Sec. Sch. Taybeh Village near Ramallah 1 class
· Birzeit Sec. Sch. /Birzeit 1 class
· Ajnadeen School / Gov. / Shweikah Avillage near Tulkarem 2 classes
· Ma'amounia Sec. Schools /Girls/ Jerusalem 5 classes
· Jenin Girls Sec. Sch./ Gov. / Jenin 3 classes
· Al-Mustaqbal Sec. Sch. / Private / Ramallah - 2 classes
· Saint Joseph Sec. Girls School / Private / Ramallah 2 classes
· AlShaheed Izzat Abu Al-Rub Sec. Boys Sch. / Qabatyya 2 classes
· Ecole De Freres Sec. Mixed School / Jerusalem 2 classes
· Shuafat High School 9 classes
· A class profile who are the individual students
in the class, their personal histories, family background, etc.
· A profile of their school curricula, subjects,
main projects, etc.
· A profile of their school and community
· Issues for discussion about the conflict and the
peace process, etc.
·
For the Israeli and
Palestinian students already taking part in the IPCRI Peace Education program
·
For all Israeli and
Palestinian students who wish to join the discussion (those who are not
involved in the IPCRI Education for Peace project)
·
For Israeli and
Palestinian educators those involved and those not involved in the IPCRI
Education for Peace project
·
For peace educators
all over the world who are interested in peace education.
1. Technical training and practice: Students and educational personnel will obtain technological training
and practice that will help them gain skills on the Internet. These skills will qualify them for
participating in today's global economy and acts as a buffer against
parochialism as well as providing additional experience and knowledge in
information technology.
2. Virtual communication bridges geographical distances: The computer encounters constitute a
"safe" means of fighting stereotypes and creating rapprochement.
Facilitated contact via the Internet will stimulate a culture of cooperation
and interaction. Encounters between participants on all levels (educators,
teachers, principals, and students) are built into the project.
3. Problem solving skills:
Students learn to express their concerns in a creative and mutually acceptable
format. They learn to work together for a constructive aim. By dealing with
projects aimed at participation, problem solving and research skills, the
participants will have a chance of refining their conflict resolution skills.
In that sense, the process of setting up, operating, and communicating through
Internet provides a powerful tool of empowerment for all its users.
4. A resource center for conflict resolution: The web pages has an indefinite life-span, and
therefore has the potential of serving as an infrastructure for wider future
usage. It will establish a virtual meeting ground for regional (and hopefully
global) conflict resolution for use by students, educators, and others.
c) Methodology
One
of the unique aspects of this project has been its continuity. We have been
fortunate to have had the opportunity to build the Education for Peace Project,
step by step, over a long period, building confidence and friendships between
the participants. Participants look forward to meeting one another and have
developed trust in one another and in the project staff.
Once
we have completed the implementation stage, the project will be in a position
to be adopted by the Ministries of Education and/or by other non-governmental
organizations. From then on, numerous schools will have access to a complete,
tested and evaluated modular package of education for peace curricula.
It
is worthwhile mentioning that the project was developed, funded and started
during the time when the peace process had more hopeful signs and higher
appraisal from both the Palestinians and Israelis. Now, two years after the
assassination of Mr. Rabin, at a time in which the peace process is virtually
at a standstill and people from both sides are not very optimistic, it is all
the more important to continue the Education for Peace project. Youngsters are
the future of each society and they should be motivated, through education for
peace, to find the courage to live with and next to each other in a peaceful
and cooperative way.